Update video

Day 21: Buffalo Chicken Finger

Eric's Rating: 9.5/10
David's Rating: 8/10
Steven's Rating: 9.5/10
Mighty Rating: 9/10

Day 20: Chicken Finger

Eric's Rating: 8.5/10
David's Rating: 9.5/10
Steven's Rating: 10/10
Mighty Rating: 9.33/10

Steve's comments: "The perfect sub. Even the pickles worked with this one, there's nothing more I could imagine being added to make it better. In short: Flawless victory."

Day 19: Buffalo Chicken Cutlet

Eric's Rating: 9/10
David's Rating: 8/10
Steven's Rating: 9/10
Mighty Rating: 8.5/10

Day 18: Chicken Cutlet Works

Eric's Rating: 8/10
David's Rating: 8/10
Steven's Rating: 7/10
Mighty Rating: 7.66/10

Day 17: Chicken Cutlet

Eric's Rating: 9/10
David's Rating: 9/10
Steven's Rating: 9/10
Mighty Rating: 9/10

Day 16: Steak Works

Eric's Rating: 7.5/10
David's Rating: 8/10
Steven's Rating: 8/10
Mighty Rating: 7.83/10

How it all began

How it all began:

Day 15: Steak & Cheese

Eric's Rating: 7/10
David's Rating: 7.5/10
Steven's Rating: 7.5/10
Mighty Rating: 7.33/10

Where is Mighty Subs?

View Larger Map

Why, it's right here. 250 Highland Ave., Needham, MA

Mid-Menu Review

Alas, we have finished side one of the menu: the cold subs. Mighty Subs prides itself on its fast service, and therefore relies heavily on their cold subs as they obviously require less preparation time. When one wants a lot of food quickly and at a great value, the Mighty Subs cold subs cannot be beat.

But being the experienced Mighty-goers that we are, we have entered this experiment - no, this journey- with the prior knowledge that the true strength of Mighty Subs lies in its hot subs. The grill may be hidden in the back, but the flavors of their hot subs are not.

So while some of the cold subs have received seemingly low Mighty rankings, they should not be discarded from the Mighty rotation. They have their roll and fill it well (no sub metaphor intended). Our goal is to rank all the Mighty subs in reference to each other, and it is common knowledge that the hot subs will rank higher.

Stay tuned. It's about to get awesome.

Day 14: The Vegetarian

Eric's Rating: 2/10
David's Rating: 3/10
Steven's Rating: 1/10
Mighty Rating: 2/10

This marks the end of the cold subs -- hot subs start tomorrow!

Day 13: Smoked Turkey

Eric's Rating: 5/10
David's Rating: 5/10
Steven's Rating: 5/10
Mighty Rating: 5/10

5/18: Edited to add Eric's Rating

Day 12: Tuna

Eric's Rating: 5/10
David's Rating: 5/10
Steven's Rating: 5/10
Mighty Rating: 5/10

Likelihood of improvement by bacon addition: 7/10

Day 11: Sliced Honey BBQ Chicken

Eric's Rating: 2/10
David's Rating: 3/10
Steven's Rating: 2/10
Mighty Rating: 2.3/10

Similarity to actual BBQ sauce: 1/10

Day 10: The Roast Beef

Eric's Rating: 7/10
David's Rating: 7/10
Steven's Rating: 7/10
Mighty Rating: 7/10

Revisions

Two changes to the Blog today:

1. The individual scores from each of our tasters have been posted
2. Revised scores have been posted as necessary
   

Day 9: The Italian

Eric's Rating: 5/10
David's Rating: 6/10
Steven's Rating: 7/10
Mighty Rating: 6/10

Day 8: Hot Capicola

Mighty Rating: 6/10
WYSIWYG: 2/10

5/11 Revision:
Eric's Rating: 6/10
David's Rating: 5/10
Steven's Rating: 6/10
New Mighty Rating: 5.6/10

Day 7: Honey Ham & Cheese

Mighty Rating: 5/10
Improvement over regular Ham & Cheese: 4/10

5/11 Revision:
Eric's Rating: 5/10
David's Rating: 5/10
Steven's Rating: 5/10
Unchanged Mighty Rating: 5/10

Day 6: Ham & Cheese

Mighty Rating: 4.16/10
WYSIWYG: 10/10

5/11 Revision:
Eric's Rating: 4/10
David's Rating: 4.5/10
Steven's Rating: 4/10
Unchanged Mighty Rating: 4.16/10

Day 5: Genoa Salami & Cheese

Mighty Rating: 5/10

5/11 Revision:
Eric's Rating: 5/10
David's Rating: 6/10
Steven's Rating: 5/10
New Mighty Rating: 5.33/10

Day 4: Crab (with Seafood)

Mighty Score: 0/10
Schadenfreude: 10/10 (Eric's score)

5/11 Revision:
Eric's Rating: 10/10
David's Rating: 0/10
Steven's Rating: 0/10
Unchanged Mighty Rating: 0/10 (Sorry Eric, it's just too damned nasty.)